MAKING SENSE OF EVERYDAY PAIN
Sarah Aldrich & Chris Eccleston, Pain Management Unit, Univ of Bath & The Royal National
Hospital for Rheumatic Diseases, Bath, UK
Aim of Investigation: To investigate the range and diversity of explanatory frames for
normal everyday pain. Methods: Following social sampling, a Q sorting pack of statements regarding
everyday and normal pain was constructed and sorted by 65 respondents. A Q factor analysis study
was undertaken from within a social constructionist framework.
Results: The factor analysis produced eight factors. These are reported in order of statistical
strength as 1) pain as malfunction, 2) pain as self-growth, 3) pain as spiritual growth, 4) pain
as alien invasion, 5) pain as coping and control, 6) pain as abuse, 7) pain as homeostatic mechanism,
& 8) pain and power. These are interpreted by factor and by the responses of exemplars loading
highly upon each factor.
Conclusions: These 8 factors are interpreted from the context of a theory of self and
identity in pain; more specifically from within a model of pain as threat to identity.
EVALUATION OF INDIVIDUAL QUALITY OF LIFE IN CANCER PATIENTS UNDERGOING PAIN TREATMENT IN
ONE ARABIC DEVELOPING COUNTRY, TUNISIA
Farhat Ben Ayed. Susanne Schleith-Amara, Henda Rai's, Dept of Medicine, National Inst for Oncology
Salah Azai'z, Tunis, Tunisia
Aim of Investigation: To elicit factors determining Quality of Life (QoL)and investigate
rating of present life in Tunisian cancer patients receiving pain treatment. A first step to approach
evaluation ofQoL in an Arabic developing country.
Methods: Assessment ofQoL of the individual by using the “Schedule for the Evaluation
of Individual Quality of Life with Direct Weighting procedure for QoL domains” (SEIQoL-DW) adjusted
by O'Boyle C.A. et al., dept of psychology, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, a standardised
semi-structured interview eliciting the most important areas of the patients life (cues), rating
and weighting cues by visual methods. Patients suffering from various cancers, under stable pain
control by drug administration or analgesic radiotherapy.
Results: 7 out of 60 interviews were incomplete. Cues elicited in descending order of
frequency were Personal health, Work, Religion, Family, Future of children. Relationships, Finances,
Leisure activities, Health of family members (O'Boyle et al.: Family, relationships, health, finances,
living conditions, work, social life, leisure activities, religion). The highest ponderation means
were attained in Personal health. Future of children, Family, Health of family members. Trend
to positive correlation between educational/economic level of the individual and SEIQoL-index.
No correlation between religious practice and SEIQoL - index.
Conclusion: This trial using original material, avoiding translation, may indicate discrepancy
in priority of cues between this population and western Europeans. The method is applicable to
our patients. Enlargement of the patient group and prospective study designs are necessary for
further confrontation between PT outcome and QoL.
TALKING TO OTHERS ABOUT PAIN: SUFFERING IN SILENCE
Angela Beese, Katherine Doyle*, Stephen Morley. Division of Psychiatry & Behavioural Sciences,
School of Medicine, Univ of Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK
Aims of Investigation: To investigate how and under what circumstances chronic pain sufferers
communicate their pain to others,
Methods: 25 chronic low back pain (CLBP) and 20 post herpetic neuralgia (PHN) patients
gave accounts of how and when they disclose pain, and their expectations of communication, to
target people (spouse, friend, family & clinic doctors). Measures of pain (MPQ) and psychological
states (HADS) and illness representation (PBPI) were taken.
Results: There were no marked differences between groups on standard measures of pain
and psychological state. Patients reported talking to others, particularly close family members,
when in pain. Most patients do not initiate talk and their expectations of others' responses are
primarily negative. Reasons for not talking are: fear of being judged negatively and being perceived
as a burden, and the expectation of others' failure to listen and understand. Patients reported
using non-verbal communication more often with close others. CLBP patients were more likely to
express a strong belief in the uncertain cause (PBPI mysterious scale) of their pain. A correlational
analysis suggested that the mysterious factor may influence when and how pain is communicated
to others.
Conclusions: Chronic pain patients exercise caution about how and when they disclose their
pain. Whether this reflects an intention not to communicate about pain or behavioural strategy
to avoid negative value judgements is not known.
Acknowledgments: Kathenne Doyle was supported by Northern & Yorkshire NHSE as a trainee
clinical psychologist.
TRANSCULTURAL OR ETHNICAL DIFFERENCE OF PAIN
Hu Yu-huan, Research Inst. ofMedicopsychology, Shihezi Med. College, Xinjiang, 832002 People's
Republic of China.
Aim of Investigation: To find the incidence or prevalence of some pain syndromes in Chinese
people if they are different from Occidentals.
Methods: Epidemiological and clinical studies were carried out more than ten years for
the patients of amputees, terminal cancer patients, migraine, herpes zoster and postoperative
pain in children. Results: Incidence of phantom pain was 8% (N=100). Pain in terminal cancer patients
(N=1549) were 28.6% and 35.5% in retrospective and prospective study respectively. The prevalence
of migraine was 0.5-0.9%. There was no PHN in 120 herpes zosters. The pain incidence after operation
(appendectomy and repair of hernia) in children was 29.8% (N=410).
Conclusions: The data mentioned above were all in the lower range as compared with that
of the western people. There was transcul-tural or ethnical difference of pain between Chinese
and Occidentals especially in chronic pain. The personality of Chinese is thinking type and western
people is feeling type. The classical traditional Chinese culture may cause more people to cultivate
the personality of thinking type which has less emotional reaction to disease or nociceptive stimulation.
THE IMPACT OF CHRONIC PAIN ON LIFE
S.M. Mohammadi*. M.A. Asghari, A.K.. Mafi*, Occupational Health Services of National Iranian
Oil Company, P.O. Box 14155-7137, Tehran, Iran.
Aim of the investigation: The aim of the present study was to examine the impact of chronic
pain on several aspects of patients' lives.
Method: Two-hundred and six male pain patients who meet the criteria for chronic pain
(i.e., pain for more than 6 months) participated in this study. The patients rated their social
and recreational activities as well as their job and marital satisfaction, currently and before
pain began. The patients also reported the amount of time spent sleeping per 24 hours at the time
of the study and before pain began.
Results: The means of above measures were compared with each other, using paired-samples
/-test. Significant differences emerged for all measures. Specifically, at the time of the study
patients reported less social activities (t = -8.26,p < . 0001) and less recreational activities
(t -= 11.35./p <.0001), compared to before pain began. In addition, at the time of the study
patients reported lower levels of job satisfaction (t= -8.59,/p < . 0001) and lower levels
of marital satisfaction (t = -6.48,/p<.0001). Patients also reported less time spent sleeping
at the time of the study, compared to before pain began (t=-6.48, p< .0001).
Conclusions: The above findings are compatible with the results of previous studies, mostly
conducted in the Western societies. That is, chronic pain has negative impacts on many aspects
of patient's life, including social and recreational activities as well as job and marital satisfaction.
Furthermore, from the findings of the present study it can be concluded that the experience of
chronic pain is associated with sleep problems. The possible clinical significance of these findings
will be discussed.
EFFECTS OF ETHNICITY AND MEDICAL ROLE CONTEXT ON PAIN DESCRIPTIONS
Rod Moore'2. Inger Bredsgaard", Tao-Kum Mao3*, Yuh-Yuan Shiau4. Dept Oral Medicine", Univ of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA; Oral Epidemiology & Public Health2, Aarhus Univ, Denmark; National Defense Medical Center3 & National Taiwan Univ4, Taipei, Taiwan.
Aims: To explore differences in use of descriptors for common pains by ethnic and medical
role contexts. Methods: A pain-by-descriptor matrix matching survey was filled out by 233 AngloAmericans
(Am), 222 Mandarin Chinese (Ch) and 231 Scandinavians matched for age, gender and occupation.
Differences by ethnicity, gender, criteria specified chronic pain (n=132) and care providers (n=181)
were analyzed by multidimensional scaling (MDS), ?. Fisher exact, ?2 tests and odds
ratios.
Results: MDS and y tests showed description similarities within ethnic groups, while there
were differences (P<.001 to .01) between ethnic groups (? stress =.24). Greatest ethnic differences
(P <0.001) were Chinese "sourish" pain concept, use of "excruciating" by
Americans, use of "shooting" by Danes and use of "horrible" by Swedes. Differences
of chronic pain patients vs. care providers within ethnic groups was (P<001) (? stress =.16),
mostly related to consistent provider use of dull-aching, deep, heavy, sharp and recurrent vs.
chronic patient responses. Gender differences within ethnic groups were only for Chinese and Scandinavian
descriptions of childbirth and menstrual pains. The results by ethnicity approached theoretical
generalizability based on mean informant accuracy levels o f Am=.59, Ch=.71, & Danes=.62 (all
?=.99) and Swedes=.63 (?=.98) for these samples.
Conclusions: There were significant and meaningful differences in pain descriptions by
ethnicity and by chronic pain patient vs. doc tor/dentist subsamples.
Acknowledgments: Supported by Grants R29 DE09945-06 & P50-DE-08229-08 NIH/ NIDR, Bethesda,
MD, USA; Danish National Health Ins Research Fund #11/215-93.
NARRATING PAIN AND CULTURE IN THE EARLY STAGES OF HEAD AND NECK CANCER
Rhonda J. Moore. Dept of Epidemiology, MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, TX 77030, USA
Aim of Investigation: Understanding the meanings patients attach to their experiences
can help researchers understand patient's experiences with cancer pain. While treatments for head
and neck cancer can alter a patient's perception of self and quality of life; few studies have
investigated the cross-cultural meanings of pain in African-American and White American early
stage head and neck cancer survivors.
Methods: 18 patients, clinically diagnosed with early stage squam-ous carcinoma of the
head and neck, between the ages of 19-85, were recruited for this study. Using qualitative methods,
including semi-structured, open-ended interviews, we examined the following issues: I) patient's
perception of pain; 2) post-operative and other treatment pain; 3) impact of pain on function;
and 4) the meaning of pain.
Results: 5 of 18 patients initially denied pain. There were gender and cultural differences
in perceived pain. All patients' linked their pain experiences to sensations of loss, in terms
of time, health, certainty, function and quality of life. All stated that pain had taken on new
meanings in their lives after cancer.
Conclusions: There is no universal truth that can be used to describe patient's experiences
with cancer pain. By situating the patient's cancer pain in the cultural contexts of their life
narrative, researchers will better understand the meaning of cancer pain in cross-cultural patient
populations.
Acknowledgments: Supported by NIH Grant R25.
INVESTIGATION THE EFFECTIVENESS OF HOLY QURAN RECITEMEMT SONG ON REDUCTION OF POST OPERATIVE
PAIN IN IRANIAN PATIENTS
A.R. Nikbakht. Ashayeri, H, Mohamadi, E, Nursing Faculty of Tehran Medical Science Univ., Toohid
SQ, Tehran, Iran
Aim of Investigation: To ivestigate the effectiveness of HOLY QURAN Song as religious
music on relieving pain after abdominal Surgery in Iranian Patients.
Method: This sudy designed at quasi-experimental design whit 60 eligible patients on two
randomized using standard scales, before and 12 hours after surgery in equal Interval in two groups
and intervention of case group was listening to HOLY QURAN chapter Yousuf (versus 7-23) with the
voice of Prof. Shahhat Mohammad Anvar for twenty minutes.
Results: Significant pin relief in 30 patients in experimental group was observed. Pain
relief varied from 8 scores to 3 in the interven-tional group and intensity change degree was
only 2 Score in control group.
Conclusion: The results show that the amount of relief obtained with QURAN song varied
considerably between patients that 30% of patients obtained maximum Possible relief specially
in adolescent male patients. And 30% obtained less than moderate Pain relief and others between
them. Our experiment conclude that listening to the HOLY QURAN reduce Pain after abdominal surgery
in Iranian patients.
Acknowledgment: Supported in part by Tarbiat Modarres uni. Tehran IRAN.
THE INDIAN PHILOSOPHY OF PAIN - ITS APPLICATION IN MODERN TIMES
G. K. Prusty, Calcutta Medical Research Inst, Dept ofNeurosur-gery, Calcutta 700 027, India
Aim of Investigation: To study the evolution of Indian philosophy on pain over the years
and its practical application in modem times.
Methods: The author has reviewed literature from Vedas, Upani-shads, Tagore, Gandhi, Vivekanand
and others; and interviewed persons involved in pain cure.
Results: Indian philosophy-cssentially the Hindu philosophy teaches not to regard the
body and its senses as be all and end all of existence. Rather it points to the need for each
of us to evolve beyond the confines placed upon by the body, the mind and the intellect to a hither
to unknown and inexperienced state of consciousness where neither pain nor pleasure matter. Such
evolution can be achieved through Yoga, service without attachment and desire, wisdom achieved
through study and meditation or true renunciation. For individuals already in the grip of severe
pain, the physical cause of which can not be eradicated, Hindu philosophy recommends therapy for
the spirit. The strengthening of he patient's inner resources and development in him of an attitude
that challenges pain can lead to augmentation of the known neuro-physiological mechanism for descending
inhibition of pain. Prescribing large doses of potent analgesics weakens the patient's spirit.
By clouding his consciousness, it will impair his ability to achieve his fullest potential during
the closing phase of his life.
CANCER PAIN CULTURAL EXPRESSION IN TUNISIAN PATIENTS
Boussen H*', Gritii S*, Bouaouina N', Hamzaoui A', Kallel M', Kallel L', Benna F", Rahal
K*, Ladgham A*, *Institut Salah Azaiz, 'Tunisian Association for Study of Pain, Tunis Tunisia.
Objective: To report the particularities of cultural expression of cancerous pain in Tunisian
patients.
Patients and methods: From September 1995 to December 1995, we collected prospectively
40 patients (26M/14F) with a 49,3 years mean age (11 to 80) with cancer of: breast (9/40), lung
(8/40) or others. Patients were of rural (25/40) and urban (15) origin. 8 patients were treatment-
specific naive (20%), 11/40 are under curative and 21 under palliative therapy. Patients have
been questioned about pain using the traduced Arabic version of the MGQP.
Results: 11 patients presented with acute and 29 with chronic pain. We observe a high
pain level with 60% > 7 in the VAS. Noising expression have been observed in 17/40 patients
with complaints, groaning and rarely crying, the rest of patients adopting a frequently silent
fatalist approach with reference to religious values. Anxiety and depression are observed in 4
patients. Rare evocation of death < 10% needs to be differentiated from mortal pain. When we
compare cancer pain to previous pain experiences, we note the valorizing value of delivery and
circumcision pain. These later arc reported as more intense but brief and non durable.
Conclusion: In our study we see two pain approaches to cancer pain , the "traditional"
fatalist Muslim (rural) and also an "occidental" (urbanised areas) view of the problem.
The valorizing aspect of delivery and circumcision pain is a particular aspect.
LIVING WITH SOMEONE WITH CHRONIC PAIN: THE IMPACT ON SIGNIFICANT OTHERS MOOD AND MARITAL ADJUSTMENT
Timothy Sharp and Michael Nicholas, Univ of Sydney Pain Management and Research Centre, Royal
North Shore Hospital, NSW 2065, Australia
Aim of Investigation: To assess the impact of living with someone who has chronic pain
on the depression and marital (dis)satisfaction of significant others (SO). In contrast to previous
research, this study will use higher, more clinically significant cut-off levels and in addition,
will investigate the role of significant other cognitions.
Methods: A number of widely used, self-report psychometric questionnaires (e.g., the Beck
Depression Inventory and the Dyadic Adjustment Scale) were administered to several hundred significant
others who attended a large, tertiary referral Pain Centre with their partners on the occasion
of their initial, multidisciplinary assessment. Analysis involved descriptive statistics and regression
analyses.
Results: The average BDI score was 8.5 and the average DAS score was 110.1. Approximately
18% of SOs had BDI scores greater than 13 and 5.4% had BDI scores greater than 21. Thirty percent
had DAS scores below 100 and 15.3% were below 90. Regression analyses suggested that a significant
proportion of both variables could be explained by SO cognitions.
Conclusions: These results suggest that the clinically significant prevalence rates of
depression and marital maladjustment was not as high in SOs as has previously been reported. Further,
these results would be consistent with a cognitive-behavioural explanation, incorporating SO's
cognitions about their partners' pain, rather than by simply attributing it to their partners'
pain or problems such as disability, Implications for treatment will be discussed.
SOCIAL CLASS AND OCCUPATIONAL FACTORS IN NECK PAIN
Aisha Syed'. De Souza* LH', McAuley JH", Frank AO2, 'Dept of Health Studies,
Brunei Univ, Isleworth TW7 5DU, UK; '•Dept of Rehabilitation, Northwick Park Hospital, Harrow
HA1 3UJ, UK
Aim of Investigation: To examine the relationship between social class, occupation and
disability of patients with neck pain.
Methods: 120 patients provided complete clinical and demographic data including current
or previous occupation which was used to identify their social class. Disability was measured
using a Neck Pain questionnaire which assessed different aspects of a patient's daily routine.
Results: Based on their current or previous occupations, patients were classified into
social class 1, e.g. Medical Practitioners = 11 (13.2%); 2, e.g. Teaching Professionals = 32 (38.4%);
3NM, e.g. Secretaries = 36 (43%); 3M, e.g. Carpenters = 16 (19.2%); 4, e.g. Caretakers = 20 (24%);
5, e.g. Cleaners = 5 (6%). Additionally five of the most common occupations were examined: Drivers
= 6 (4.6%), Secretaries = 43 (33.1%), Nurses = 11 (8.4%), Teachers = 10 (7.1%)), Managers = 13
(10.0%). No significant differences were found between the social class categories (F=0.66, P=0.65)
or the occupational groups in terms of disability. Although managers had the highest mean score
in disability (17.2), this was not significantly different from the other four occupational groups
(P=0.19).
Conclusion: Three conclusions are drawn. Firstly patients attending a specialist neck
pain clinic represent diverse social and occupational groups and are therefore not a homogenous
group of patients. Secondly, it was found that there were no significant differences in the mean
disability scores between social class and the occupational groups. Although secretaries were
the most common occupational group, there was no difference in disability between this and the
others. Lastly, although not significant, it was found that the managers had the highest mean
disability score. This finding merits further investigation as this group may be at particular
risk for developing neck pain disability.
SOCIOCULTURAL VARIABLES AND CHRONIC PAIN PATIENTS ATITTUDES
Pimenta CAM; Cruz DALM; Teixeira MJ; Castro VD; Paes AT. Nursing School of Univ ofSao Paulo,
League Against Pain. Hospital das Clinicas ofUniv ofSao Paulo. Av. Eneas de C. Aguiar, 419, Sao
Paulo, 05403-000, Brazil.
Aim of Investigation: To analyze the association between pain attitudes and the demographic,
social-cultural and pain characteristics variables; to compare the pain attitudes in the beginning
of the pain treatment and 6 to 15 months after.
Methods: The pain attitudes of 69 patients presenting cancer (24), myofascial (27), neurophatic
(14), and undetermined (4) pain were assessed through Brief Version of Survey of Pain Atitudes,
valited to Portuguese language. Twenty-one of these patients had a 2nd assessment.
The variables studied were: sex, age, origin, schooling, religion, pain etiology, duration and
intensity of pain complain, number of consultation and the attendance or not at a chronic pain
program. Parametric and non-parametric tests were applied with the significance level at 0.05.
Results: The medians of the attitudes were: control-1 (best=4); incapacity-3 (best=0);
harm-3 (best=0); emotion-3 (best=4); medication-3 (best=0); solicitude-2 (best=0), and medical
cure-4 (best=0). Cancer pain patients had higher scores in disability and medication. Men agree
stronger that medical cure is possible for chronic pain. There was a positive correlation between
aging and the concept that medication is the best treatment for pain and a negative correlation
between schooling and solicitude. Patients originated from most undeveloped regions of Brazil
agree stronger that solicitous responses from others are appropnate and that medication is the
best treatment for chronic pain. Pain attitudes don't change between the 1st and 2"'1
assessment.
Conclusion: Maladjusted chronic pain attitudes were observed. Sociocultural and demographics
variables and pain etiology were associated with specific attitudes.
THE PAIN BELIEFS QUESTIONNAIRE: A STUDY INVOLVING HEALTHY SUBJECTS
Anne Rhys-Williams, School of Occupational Therapy and Physiotherapy, Univ of East Anglia, Norwich,
UK.
Aim of Investigation: A comparison of the factor analysis of the Pain Beliefs Questionnaire
(PBQ) as reported by Edwards et al (1992), with that of a healthy student population.
Methods: The 12 item PBQ, reflecting common beliefs regarding the experience of pain,
its causes, consequences and factors influencing its seventy, designed by Edwards et al (1992)
was replicated using the same format and instructions. 187 questionnaires were distributed to
students of the School of Health, Univ of East Anglia.
Results: The men age of the healthy student population was 22.60 years (SD 5.35), and
88.9% were female. 153 questionnaires were completed (81.82%), and these responses were subjected
to Principal Components Analysis. Five factors were obtained with an Eigenvalue over 1, accounting
for 63.3% of the variance. Conclusions: The present study failed to replicate the two clear, discrete
classes of beliefs about pain obtained by Edwards et al (1992). This may be due to the differences
in the sample populations, predominantly young females compared with a mixed sample which included
chronic pain patients. Thus, the PBQ cannot be recommended as a reliable measure of pain beliefs
in a healthy student population.
Reference: Edwards LC, Pearce SA, Tumer-Stokes L and Jones A (1992). The Pain Beliefs
Questionnaire: an investigation of beliefs in the causes and consequences of pain. Pain 51:267-272.
GENDER DIFFERENCES IN THE IMPACT OF PAIN: A COMPARISON OF THREE CHRONIC/ RECURRENT PAIN CONDITIONS
Linda LeResche. Michael Von Korff, Samuel Dworkin, Kathleen Saunders*, Univ of Washington Dept.
of Oral Medicine, Seattle, WA 98195-6370 (USA), and Group Health Cooperative ofPuget Sound
Aim of Investigation: To investigate gender differences in measures of pain severity and
pain impact.
Methods: Subjects were 574 male and 638 female back pain (BP) patients, 225 male and 554
female headache (HA) patients, and 69 male and 328 female temporo-mandibular disorder (TMD) patients
making primary care visits for pain in a large health maintenance organization. Subjects reported
pain intensity and interference on numeric scales; pain days, use of health care for pain and
pain-related disability days in the past 6 months; and opioid use in the past month. Depression
was assessed with the SCL-90.
Results: For all pain conditions, characteristic pain intensity was higher for women than
for men (BP: 55 vs. 48; HA 57 vs. 51; TMD 52 vs. 44, all p's < .001). Women reported more days
in pain than their male counterparts (BP: 88 vs. 68; HA: 57 vs. 50 -n.s.; TMD 96 vs. 73), more
disability days (BP: 24 vs. 16; HA: 11 vs. 7; TMD 11 vs. 6 - n.s.), and more pain-related interference.
Other impacts differed by pain site. Women with BP and HA were more likely to have elevated depression
scores, but rates of depression in TMD did not differ by gender. Slightly more men than women
with BP and TMD were unemployed, whereas unemployment in HA patients was significantly higher
for women than for men. Use of opioids and health care did not differ by gender for any of the
conditions.
Conclusions: Women are generally more severely impacted by pain than men, but patterns
of pain impact differ somewhat by clinical condition.
Acknowledgments: Supported by N1H Grant No. DE08773 (USA).
CIRCUMCISION, CULTURE AND PAIN
Ngoitsi Henry Nono*. College of Health Sciences, Univ of Nairobi, Kenya (SPON: D. Ndetei)
Aim: To establish the influence of culture in containing the pain of male circumcision
in Kenyan societies. Methods: Secondary data, Personal experience, Literature search
Results: Circumcision, which involves surgical removal of the prepuce and exposure of
the glans penis, is a cultural requirement in many Kenyan societies. This involves the infliction
of severe pain since no anaesthesia is used. Sometimes stinging traditional herbs are applied
on the cut to serve as antiseptic. To prove his worth as a man the candidate is not expected to
show any indication of suffering. Studies show that response to pain varies with culture, gender,
age environment and even individuals.
Conclusion: The author concludes that cultural expectation can serve as a tool to accommodate
severe pain. The pain endured at circumcision prepares the men to tackle the stress of adult life.
Acknowledgment: Prof. Violet Kimani, Dept of Community Health; Prof. D. Ndetei, Dept of
Psychiatry; Dr. A.A. Indalo, Dept of Clinical Pharmacology, Univ of Nairobi.
PSYCHOPHYSICAL SCALING OF NOXIOUS ELECTRICAL PULSES: GENDER DIFFERENCES
G.B. Rollman & M. Hervieux*, Dept of Psychology, The Univ of Western Ontario, London, Ontario
Canada N6A 5C2
Aim of Investigation: Many earlier studies, including some in this laboratory [Lautenbacher
& Rollman, Pain, 53 (1993) 255-264; Rollman & Hams, Perception & Psychophysics, 42
(1987) 257-268] have shown that women, on average, have significantly lower pain threshold and
pain tolerance to noxious electrocutanc-ous stimuli than do men. Our data have also suggested
that the growth ofpsychophysical functions, relating perceived intensity to current, show a steeper
slope for women than for men. Those findings, however, were based on fixed stimulus ranges. In
this study, to compensate for different dynamic ranges, individually-tailored stimulus ranges
were employed.
Methods: 20 male and 20 female undergraduates used a Gracely box scale, in which scaled
numerical values were matched to verbal descriptors of pain intensity and unpleasantness. Seven
electrical stimuli, spanning the range between pain threshold and .9 (pain tolerance), were randomly
presented to the hand, 4 times each, in blocks where subjects rated intensity or unpleasantness
of the resulting experience.
Results: As before, pain threshold and tolerance levels were markedly lower in women than
in men. Also, as before, there are sizeable individual differences in pain responsiveness. The
data suggested that both intensity and unpleasantness grew at a faster rate in women than in men.
Conclusions: Sex differences in the response to noxious stimuli, particularly those (such
as electrical pulses) which may cause differential levels of anxiety, are often marked. Scaling
studies which used a fixed range were unable to include some subjects, particularly female ones,
whose tolerance was below the higher stimulus levels. These data, based upon all subjects, still
suggest differential evaluation of these stimuli. As well, they indicate that gender differences
occur for both the sensory and the affective components of the pain experience.
Acknowledgments: Supported in part by a NSERC research grant to the first author.
PAIN IN PAINTING ART
Sigmund Emhjellen, Ulleval Hospital, Dept of Anaesthesia, 0407 Oslo, Norway
Aim of Investigation: Pain, suffering and anxiety have been depicted from antiquity to
present by artists. To present such work of art to health personnel involved in acute and chronic
pain therapy is important.
Methods: About 30 museums in Europe and America have been visited over the last years
in order to select and study paintings that incorporate suffering, pain and anxiety as a main
theme.
Results: About 24 paintings will be presented. Each painting will be evaluated and its
historical background presented.
Conclusions: History of Medicine and Pain is an important topic on most IASP congresses
but Pain in Art has so far not been listed as a topic. It is my hope that this contribution might
change this.
EUTHANASIA IN COLOMBIA
Rene Rodriguez. Coordinador de la Clinica para alivio del dolor y Cuidados Paliativos Institute
de los Seguros Sociales, Cali, Colombia.
Aim of Investigation: To investigate the euthanasia concept managed by Colombian physicians
who work with terminal patients; frequency of the requirement and the physicians' reactions.
Methods: The trial was developed using inquiry system in several congresses and also inquiries
were mailed to physicians in the main cities of Colombia. Statistical work was done with absolute
frequency, relative frequency, proportion and comparison of variables.
Results: 78 answers were considered able to be studied. 50% of the physicians had received
requirements to practice euthanasia from their patients mainly. If the patients were suffering
and requested euthanasia, 40% of the physicians accept to practice euthanasia. 83% of the physicians
were Catholic. 30% accepted to have practiced active euthanasia and 62% passive euthanasia and
12% assisted suicide.
Conclusions: Many Colombian physicians have practiced euthanasia to terminal patients.
We must improve palliative care in our institutions.
THREAT TO HUMAN PROGRESS IS MAINLY THE DRUG MENANCE, HIV/AIDS AND SOCIO-POLITICAL MISDIRECTION
Duodu Ofoe Michael*. David Nkrumah Adasa*, Charles Acheam-pong*, James Doe Sablah*, Pastor Christine
Ofori Acheampong*, Emelia Adiyiah*.
Aims: To expose the courses of most kinds of pain in Africa. Methods: Many people were
interviewed, district by district up to the national level.
Results: The present economic problems leading to broken down morals worldwide and loss
of cultural values globally are building the scene for illicit drugs, sex and prostitution; presenting
man with a dangerous and fearful harm of our age. Many young men and women take solace in drugs.
Once in drugs, they become vulnerable to HIV infections as they carelessly exchange needles during
their illicit drug intake; Grief, hopelessness and helplessness therefore set in, looking at the
costs needed to redeem those youths. In the case of HIV infection, frustration becomes part of
the problem as there is no known cure yet.
Conclusion: We need a conceited efforts to improve upon our Sociopolitical and economic
bases and give good moral training to the youth. This would help discard the notion where developing
nations have accepted human suffering as a necessary pain in life.
9th WORLD CONGRESS ON PAIN, 1999, Vienna, Austria, p.353 - 357
|